Understanding Lead Scoring: The Complete Guide to Qualifying Leads

If they’re in the right job role, location, or industry, that’s often enough for a sales rep to prioritize that prospect. On the flip side, they might also disqualify anyone who doesn’t tick the right boxes. But, if you ask marketing, you could get a completely different idea of what a hot lead is. For them, a prospect who downloads multiple case studies or regularly opens your emails should be considered the top priority.

The answer lies somewhere in the middle and the best way to reach it is with effective lead scoring. 

A robust lead-scoring system not only aligns your teams but also ensures you’re investing time and resources in the prospects that are both in line with your ICP and most likely to make a purchase. The result? Improved productivity, enhanced efficiency, and higher revenue.

Note: Leadfeeder identifies companies that visit your site, even if they don't fill out a form. Sign up for a free two-week trial and discover the companies visiting your site today.

What is lead scoring?

Lead scoring is a method of assigning numerical values to leads based on how likely they are to become potential customers. Lead scorers assign points to each lead based on the likelihood that they’ll convert into customers and use those numbers to identify which leads should be given more attention.

Lead scoring systems generally consider historical and behavioral data about a lead; for example, this includes whether or not they've visited your website before, how often they've downloaded content from your website, or how long it took them to respond to an email.

Understanding the importance of lead scoring

Knowing which leads to pursue can be tricky. Failing to differentiate a hot lead from a cold one could mean missing out on revenue—worse still, you could be wasting time and resources on leads that go nowhere. 

Chasing a cold lead for months while leaving a potential customer by the wayside is never a good look.

Part of the problem is the disconnect between sales and marketing teams. What seems like a priority lead for one team may not be the case for another. 

For example, a sales rep might have a positive conversation with a lead who seems really interested in your business, but the marketing team knows this person has never visited the website, attended one of your events, downloaded a case study, etc. 

Conversely, marketing might keep passing leads to sales that the sales team has already disqualified.

That’s where lead scoring comes in. With a robust lead scoring process in place, businesses can categorize and prioritize leads according to an objective quality rating. 

Sales and marketing departments can work collaboratively to develop lead-scoring models that reflect a potential customer's interest in the business and arrive at an agreed definition of what constitutes a hot lead. 

This means marketing and sales are aligned on the quality of leads, making it quicker to engage prospects, close deals, and measure the performance of your sales reps.

Establishing a solid lead scoring system empowers you to optimize your marketing strategies, ensuring resources are invested where they’ll have the greatest impact. The more confident you are in the quality of a lead, the more confident you can be in predicting revenue streams, too, allowing you to assess your pipeline and revenue forecasts more accurately.

Focusing on the prospects more likely to convert means better business outcomes all round, saving precious resources, improving collaboration, and accelerating the buyer journey. 

Lead scoring is an effective way to identify these hot prospects and ensure your organization invests time and money in the right people.

Lead scoring types 

Now you understand the importance of lead scoring, you’re probably wondering how exactly to categorize these leads. You can take several approaches to lead scoring types, which will be based on the nature, size, and goals of your business.

Manual lead scoring

Manual lead scoring involves teams manually assessing certain criteria to give leads a numerical or qualitative label. These criteria might include factors like demographics, engagement, and behavior, including:

• Job title

• Industry

• Company size

• Email opens

• Website visits

• Resource downloads

Using this information, teams will assign a lead score to each prospect based on their likelihood of converting into customers. 

These scores could be categorized as hot, medium, or cold, or you might assign a numerical value (e.g., from 1-100) for more precise scoring.

The benefit of manual lead scoring is that it allows businesses to be more nuanced in their approach. This is especially useful for niche companies that have a very specific or unpredictable target market. 

It also provides flexibility to adjust scoring based on real-time market or business changes.

However, manual lead scoring is a resource-intensive, time-consuming process. 

Getting your teams together to evaluate leads regularly removes them from other, higher-value tasks. It’s also a risky approach as it’s more prone to errors, and subjectivity may impede the process.

Predictive lead scoring

Predictive lead scoring uses big data, machine learning, and AI to rank leads based on their likelihood of converting automatically.

While manual scoring involves human judgment and predefined criteria, predictive lead scoring analyzes historical data to identify patterns and key indicators of successful conversions. 

This method evaluates multiple factors, such as demographic information, behavioral data, and brand interactions, to assign lead scores.

Lead scoring predictive analytics allows businesses to identify high-potential leads more accurately and in real time. Because the system is constantly learning, updating, and adapting from new data, the scoring process is refined over time. 

This makes it particularly valuable for companies with large volumes of leads or complex sales cycles, as it allows for faster and more consistent lead prioritization.

This data-driven approach enables sales teams to focus on leads with the highest probability of closing, reducing the time and resources spent on low-quality prospects. 

It also eliminates much of the subjectivity of manual scoring, as decisions are based on robust data rather than opinions or gut instincts.

The success of predictive analytics is dependent on the quality of the lead scoring tools, CRM systems, and marketing tools you have in place. 

No matter the size or scope of your business, implementing robust and reliable technology is essential to maximize the accuracy, efficiency, and value of predictive lead scoring.

What data do you need for lead scoring?

Both manual and predictive lead-scoring models rely on good-quality data. The more data you have, the more accurate you can be in identifying which prospects are more likely to become customers. This data should include:

1) Demographic data

Demographic data covers personal details about the lead, such as job title, location, and age. For B2B companies, job roles are particularly important as they indicate whether the lead has decision-making authority or influence. 

Other factors like age or income are more relevant for B2C organizations where understanding the consumer’s profile is key to predicting purchasing decisions.

2) Firmographic data

In B2B lead scoring, firmographic data focuses on the organization the lead represents. This includes company size, revenue, industry, and location. 

These factors help determine whether the company is a good fit for the product or service offered. For example, a software company targeting mid-sized businesses may prioritize leads from companies with 100-500 employees.

3) Behavioral data

Behavioral data tracks how leads engage with your brand. It includes actions like website visits, email clicks, content downloads, event or webinar attendance, and interactions with social media. 

If leads frequently engage with your marketing materials, their behavior indicates a strong interest in your business, meaning they’re more likely to convert.

4) Technographic and intent data

Technographic data covers the technology stack a company uses. This is useful for B2B companies where compatibility with the lead’s existing systems may affect their buying decisions. 

Intent data also provides valuable insights into topics a lead is researching, indicating their readiness to purchase.

To benefit from your lead scoring tool, you’ll want to collect data from various sources, including:

• Marketing tools

Marketing analytics tools can provide a wealth of information about your potential customers’ behaviors and preferences. You can track a number of key metrics, including email open and click-through rates, resource downloads, website visits, and conversion rates. 

You can even see how much revenue your marketing activities have generated, giving you an idea of which individuals are more likely to turn into customers.

All this data can be incorporated into your lead scoring system to help you determine which leads are high priority. For example, prospects who have opened all your emails, clicked all the links, and spent a significant amount of time on your website clearly show significant interest in your business. 

This data helps nurture highly engaged prospects to accelerate them along the customer journey.

• Sales teams

Your sales team is out in the market, talking to prospects and customers daily. Finding out what they find useful in the sales process will guide you in engaging prospects effectively and understanding their preferences. 

For example, a sales rep might tell you a particular case study always gains a lot of interest, or they close deals faster after the prospect has attended one of your events.

• Customers

Sometimes, you have to go directly to the source. Speaking to customers and finding out what compelled them to convert will help you understand their reasons for buying from you. 

You might be surprised at what they reveal, or your discussion might validate your suspicions. Consider sending out regular customer feedback surveys or setting up interviews to talk in-depth about their experiences.

Do you only need one lead score?

A one-size-fits-all approach might work if you only have one core customer. But chances are you’ll likely target several markets—especially as your company grows into new territories and product lines. 

Your focus might shift from acquiring new customers to cross-selling and up-selling existing ones.

You’ll need a lead scoring tool with more than one lead scoring system to manage this. This will allow you to segment and categorize different prospects effectively, ensuring the lead score reflects the quality of that particular market.

1) Multiple personas

B2B companies often deal with prospects in different departments and roles. For example, they might have to win over an operational manager by showing the value of their product or service, but they also have to convince a financial executive that the return is worth the investment.

Each persona has a different set of needs and goals that drives their behavior. That’s why it makes sense to score these two personas differently; this will help you gauge their level of interest and avoid mislabeling prospects with an ineffective lead-scoring process.

2) Fit vs. interest

A prospect might come along that ticks all the right boxes. They’re a perfect fit for their job role, industry, region, etc., but they’ve shown little interest in your business. On paper, they sound like a hot lead, but their lack of engagement is a red flag.

Scoring prospects on a fit vs. interest basis is one of the most important lead-scoring examples. A single score would be misleading, but separating fit and interest gives you a more accurate overview of that prospect’s intentions.

3) Product/service specific

If you offer multiple types of products or services, your contacts will likely come from various markets and backgrounds. For example, if you’re a software company selling CRM and accounting solutions, you’ll probably have different ideal customer profiles for each product. 

Having separate lead scores for these personas ensures leads are assessed effectively and passed onto the correct product team.

Lead scoring models 

There are several approaches you can take when it comes to lead scoring. Depending on the nature of your business and the prospects you’re hoping to target, you might choose a system that values high engagement rates or prioritizes prospects based on their demographic data. 

You might even prefer a negative scoring approach, disqualifying unsuitable leads according to certain information and behaviors.

No matter which lead scoring model example appeals to you, you must pick the right system for your needs and implement it successfully. 

Let’s take a closer look at some common lead-scoring models and discover which one is the right fit for your business.

1) Demographic data

If you’re selling a product or service to one specific market, scoring leads based on demographic information might be the right option for you. This lets you quickly and easily identify the leads that fit your criteria and remove any outliers.

For example, if you sell luxury fashion products, you may only go after leads with a minimum annual income of $100,000 or live in an affluent urban area with higher demand for luxury fashion. 

If you’re an enterprise software company, you’ll likely want to target leads with a minimum of 1000+ employees and annual revenues exceeding $100 million.

2) Behavioral scoring

Behavioral scoring focuses on a lead's actions, such as website visits, content downloads, email engagement, or event attendance. Each action is assigned a value, with high-engagement behaviors (e.g., requesting a demo) receiving higher scores. 

This model identifies leads with active interest in the product or service, helping sales teams prioritize those more likely to convert.

Many companies and individuals use project management software. In this case, trying to prioritize leads based on demographics would be impossible, but assessing their interest level based on behavior would be more effective. 

If they’re visiting pricing pages, requesting demos, and downloading case studies, this gives you a better idea of their intentions and likelihood of converting.

3) Engagement models

Tracking how often a lead engages with your brand indicates how interested they are in your products. An engagement model helps assign scores to leads based on their activity, signaling a lead’s readiness for further sales outreach.

You can track your email campaigns' open and click-through rates, for instance, or measure how often an individual likes, comments, or shares your social media posts. 

Once the lead has taken certain actions or accumulated enough points, you can pass them on to the sales team.

4) Predictive lead scoring

One of the newest lead scoring model examples is predictive lead scoring. This is where lead scoring tools use machine learning and historical data to identify patterns that predict lead conversion. 

The tools analyze demographic and behavioral data and create a predictive model that scores leads based on their conversion likelihood. 

The benefit of this model, besides the time it saves and the bias it reduces, is that it constantly improves as more data is gathered, making it more dynamic than traditional scoring methods.

This lead scoring system often goes hand in hand with automated lead generation software. Combining these two solutions means you can continuously gather and nurture leads by triggering personalized marketing campaigns, tracking behavior, and updating scores in real time. 

The result is that your business can scale your lead generation efforts while focusing on more valuable prospects, ultimately improving efficiency and driving better conversion rates without manual intervention.

Should you use lead scoring software?

Manually scoring leads is often time-consuming and ineffective. Not only do you increase the chance of errors, but you also leave yourself open to subjectivity and bias. 

This is valuable time your team could spend on more important revenue-generating tasks like optimizing marketing strategies and closing deals.

Lead scoring software automates this tedious process to streamline workflows, free up resources, and give you confidence in your scoring system. 

Using data-driven algorithms, the software can objectively rank leads based on factors like demographic fit, behavior, and engagement. 

One of the benefits of using lead scoring software is that it continuously updates in real time, meaning your team always has up-to-date information at their fingertips.

The other advantage of lead scoring software is the amount of behavioral data it can consider. While your teams can manually identify if a lead has the budget, authority, need, and timeline to make a purchase, a lead-scoring solution can provide useful insights into behaviors and intent. 

For example, it can track website visits, event attendance, and content downloads. Explicit factors like job role and industry might indicate a good fit, but this behavioral information is a more powerful sign of a lead’s interest level.

This automation boosts productivity and helps align sales and marketing efforts, leading to more effective lead nurturing, higher conversion rates, and improved revenue outcomes.

Use lead scoring best practices to create a successful roadmap

As we’ve seen, an effective lead-scoring process brings many benefits and improved business outcomes. But how can you make sure your system is set up for success? 

Follow these lead-scoring best practices to benefit from your solution:

1) Encourage collaboration across teams

A successful lead-scoring system relies on input from both sales and marketing teams. Marketing might have access to information on lead behavior, but sales have a deeper understanding of which leads are more likely to convert.

To develop a scoring model incorporating these insights, both teams must work together to define the ideal customer profile. This means collaborating to identify high-impact behaviors, determine scoring criteria, and agree on a process that works for everyone.

This shared understanding of what makes a lead valuable keeps both teams aligned on how to nurture leads and when to pass them from marketing to sales.

2) Check and verify your data

To ensure your lead scoring is accurate, you’ll need to ensure your data is accurate, too. Incorrect or outdated information can lead to misleading scores, resulting in teams wasting time and resources on the wrong prospects.

Keep on top of your data sources regularly to ensure they’re reliable and up to date. Validate key demographic, firmographic, and behavioral data so the scoring is as up-to-date as possible. 

For example, you might consider using phone number and email validation tools to confirm whether numbers and email addresses are current and reachable. 

You should also check your marketing tools to ensure they’re tracking and recording relevant behaviors accurately. Testing key user actions, such as filling out forms or clicking on CTAs, can help verify accurate tracking.

3) Leverage technology to maximize success

Automated lead scoring tools are essential to get ahead of the competition. Advanced technologies like lead scoring predictive analytics can save time, eliminate human bias, and predict conversion likelihood. 

These tools continuously evolve and adapt based on new data, ensuring you have recent information to act on and providing real-time updates to your sales and marketing teams.

4) Continuously monitor and adjust

Lead scoring is not a “set it and forget it” process. Buyer behaviors, market conditions, and business priorities evolve, and your scoring system should adapt accordingly. 

Regularly review your scoring criteria and the performance of your leads in the sales funnel. Analyze which leads convert more successfully than others and adjust your scoring model to reflect these trends better. 

Monitoring key metrics, such as lead-to-conversion rates, will help you fine-tune your system for optimal results, ensuring your lead-scoring roadmap remains relevant and effective.

Bottom Line: Data is the key to successful lead scoring

While there is no one right way to qualify leads, effective lead scoring will always require collaboration, careful data management, and the right technology. 

Following key best practices, including fostering alignment between teams, verifying data accuracy, and regularly refining your scoring model, will empower you to prioritize the right leads and optimize resources confidently. 

Meanwhile, a high-quality lead scoring tool can automate analysis of key behavioral and demographic information to accelerate sales cycles, boost conversion rates, and drive more revenue for your business.

A data-driven approach to lead generation ensures your teams are always focused on the highest-value opportunities while paying close attention to buyer intent data—especially in ABM—increases lead scoring effectiveness by identifying ICP accounts that have visited your site.

Not sure where to get that intent data? Leadfeeder tracks the on-site behavior of companies—even if they never fill out a form. You can see how many pages they viewed, their location, and more. 

The result? Increased efficiency, happier teams, and higher ROI. 

Note: Leadfeeder identifies which companies visit your site—and what they do when they arrive. Sign up for a two-week trial and get access to more sales qualification data.